AutoCarReviewSpace
Every new car starts losing money the moment it leaves the forecourt. The typical car sheds 20-30% of its value in the first year alone, and around 45.6% over five years. Knowing which models beat that curve - and which accelerate through it - is the difference between a sensible purchase and an expensive mistake.
Key takeaways:
- Toyota dominates value retention - 6 of the top 10 slowest-depreciating models in 2025 are Toyotas, with the Corolla Cross ranked first overall
- EVs depreciate worst - electric vehicles lose 58.8% of their value after five years, far above the 45.6% industry average
- Trucks and hybrids win - pickup trucks lose just 34.8% after five years; hybrids average 40.7%
- The 4Runner is exceptional - Toyota's off-roader loses only 30.2% after five years, versus a 46.9% average for its segment
- Buying two to three years used lets you avoid the steepest depreciation hit while keeping most of a car's useful life
How Depreciation Actually Works
A new car loses between 9% and 11% of its value the moment you drive off the forecourt. That's before you've covered a single mile. By the end of year one, that figure climbs to 20-30%.
After year one, the rate slows to around 15% per year for the next four years. By the five-year mark, the typical car is worth less than half what you paid for it.
Why the First Year Hurts Most
The first-year drop isn't arbitrary - it reflects the psychological gap between "new" and "used." A car with 1,000 miles on it is fundamentally less attractive to most buyers than one with zero, and the market prices that accordingly.
Mileage, condition, reliability reputation, and supply all affect resale value. But brand and model choice are the biggest determinants - far more than how carefully you look after the car.
The Toyota Factor
Toyota is the clearest answer to the question of which brand holds its value best. Six of the ten slowest-depreciating models in 2025 are Toyotas. The brand retains 72.6% of its value after three years, 63.6% after five years, and 54.6% after seven - numbers that no rival comes close to matching across such a broad range of models.
Toyota's resale dominance comes from three things: a reputation for mechanical reliability built over decades, consistently high demand for used models, and supply discipline that keeps residual values from collapsing.
Toyota's Top Value Holders
- Toyota Corolla Cross - ranked first for lowest depreciation among mainstream models in 2025
- Toyota 4Runner - loses only 30.2% after five years, versus a 46.9% segment average
- Toyota Tacoma - consistently in the top five for overall five-year resale value
- Toyota Tundra - holds its value alongside the Tacoma in the full-size truck segment
- Toyota Highlander - top 10 overall for retained value across all vehicle types
The 4Runner figure deserves emphasis. Losing 16 percentage points less than the average rival in its class is not a marginal advantage - it's the difference between a car that costs you 30p in the pound versus one that costs you nearly 47p.
The Exception: Toyota's EVs
Toyota's EV credibility hasn't transferred to its residual values. The Toyota bZ4X dropped 50.1% in its first three years - a rate that would be unremarkable for most brands but is genuinely striking for a Toyota badge. Even the most reliable brand can't escape the structural forces pulling EV values down.
EV Depreciation: The Real Numbers
Electric vehicles depreciate faster than any other vehicle type, losing 58.8% of their value after five years. That compares to 45.6% for the average car and just 34.8% for trucks.
The worst examples are severe. The Jaguar I-Pace loses 72.2% of its value - roughly £40,000 - over five years. The Nissan Leaf is down 64.1%. Even premium Teslas haven't been spared: the Model Y dropped 56.6%, the Model X 55.2%, the Model 3 53.3%.
Why EVs Lose Value So Fast
Two forces are at work. First, battery technology is improving quickly enough that a 2019 EV feels genuinely outdated by 2025 - limited range, slower charging, fewer software features. Second, new EV incentives make new models more attractive relative to used ones, which suppresses the second-hand market.
US EV sales fell around 40% in late 2025 following changes to federal incentives, which pushed resale values down further. The depreciation curve for EVs is partly structural - it's tied to how fast the technology is moving, not just how the cars are made.
The Used EV Opportunity
Falling EV values are bad news for current owners but a genuine opportunity for buyers. A three-year-old EV at 50-55% off its original price can represent strong value if you're buying for daily use and plan to keep it long-term. The risk is further price deterioration if newer, longer-range models keep arriving.
Trucks and Hybrids: The Quiet Winners
Trucks lose less value than almost any other vehicle type. Pickup trucks depreciate by just 34.8% over five years, nearly 11 percentage points below the industry average. Toyota leads here too, with the Tacoma and Tundra near the top of every resale ranking.
The reason is structural: trucks serve working roles - towing, hauling - that don't become obsolete, demand consistently outstrips supply in key markets, and the used truck buyer base is large and price-stable.
Hybrids are holding their own for value retention. They lose just 40.7% after five years - better than the industry average and dramatically better than full EVs. As buyers grow more cautious about committing to fully electric, hybrids have benefited from stable resale demand on the used market.
The Worst Offenders
The fastest-depreciating vehicles share a pattern: they tend to be expensive at launch, sit in categories with falling demand, or carry brand premiums the used market doesn't support.
Worst Five-Year Depreciation
| Model | 5-Year Depreciation | Approx. Value Lost |
|---|---|---|
| Jaguar I-Pace | 72.2% | ~£40,000 |
| BMW 7 Series | 67.1% | ~£50,000 |
| Maserati Ghibli | 64.7% | ~£55,000 |
| Nissan Leaf | 64.1% | ~£14,000 |
| Tesla Model Y | 56.6% | ~£30,000 |
| Tesla Model X | 55.2% | ~£55,000 |
| Tesla Model 3 | 53.3% | ~£22,000 |
The BMW 7 Series case is instructive. Losing 67.1% of its value means a buyer who paid £75,000 new gets back around £25,000 five years later. The luxury premium that justified the price new evaporates fast in the used market, where buyers can access near-identical spec for far less.
Best vs Worst: Full Comparison
| Model | Type | 5-Year Depreciation | Retained Value |
|---|---|---|---|
| Toyota Corolla Cross | Compact crossover | ~10% | ~90% |
| Toyota 4Runner | Midsize SUV | 30.2% | 69.8% |
| Honda Civic | Compact car | ~28% | ~72% |
| Porsche 911 | Sports car | ~28% | ~72% |
| Toyota Tacoma | Pickup truck | ~33% | ~67% |
| Industry average | All vehicles | 45.6% | 54.4% |
| Tesla Model Y | EV | 56.6% | 43.4% |
| Nissan Leaf | EV | 64.1% | 35.9% |
| BMW 7 Series | Luxury saloon | 67.1% | 32.9% |
| Jaguar I-Pace | Luxury EV | 72.2% | 27.8% |
New vs Used: When the Maths Work
Buying two to three years old is where the numbers usually favour you. The first-year owner absorbs the sharpest depreciation hit - that 20-30% drop. If you buy the same car at age two or three, you've sidestepped that loss and still have most of the car's mechanical life remaining.
For models with strong resale values - Toyota, Honda, Porsche - the calculus sometimes flips. If a car barely depreciates in year one, the used premium over new becomes minimal. In those cases, buying new with a full warranty and potentially low-interest finance can be equally rational.
One Exception to Watch
Any EV over three years old needs a battery health check before you buy. Degraded battery capacity is the biggest risk with used EVs and isn't always visible without specialist diagnostic tools. Factor in a potential battery replacement cost when valuing an older EV against its asking price.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: How much does a new car depreciate in the first year? Most new cars lose between 20% and 30% of their value in the first year. A car loses 9-11% the instant it's driven off the forecourt, before any miles are added. The rate then slows to around 15% per year from year two onwards.
Q: Which brand holds its value best? Toyota is the clear leader, retaining 72.6% of its value after three years and 63.6% after five. Kelley Blue Book named Toyota and Lexus the brands with the best overall resale value in 2025. Subaru and Honda also consistently outperform the market average.
Q: Do electric vehicles depreciate faster than petrol cars? Yes, significantly. EVs lose 58.8% of their value after five years versus the 45.6% industry average. Rapid improvements in battery technology and shifting EV incentives have pushed used EV values down sharply. Toyota's bZ4X lost 50.1% in just three years - unusually fast even by EV standards.
Q: What type of vehicle holds its value best? Pickup trucks depreciate the least, losing only 34.8% of their value after five years. Hybrids perform second-best at 40.7%. Luxury vehicles and EVs depreciate fastest, often losing more than 60% of their value in five years.
Q: Is the Toyota 4Runner worth buying for resale value? The 4Runner loses just 30.2% after five years, against a 46.9% average for its class. That 16-percentage-point gap is unusually large for a single segment. For buyers who hold cars for five years or more, the 4Runner's value retention meaningfully offsets its higher purchase price.
Q: Should I buy new or used to beat depreciation? For most models, buying two to three years old lets someone else absorb the steepest first-year drop. For high-retention models like the Toyota Corolla Cross or Honda Civic, where first-year depreciation is minimal, buying new with a full warranty is often equally rational.
The Bottom Line
Depreciation isn't a detail to worry about after you've chosen a car - it's a core part of the total cost of ownership that should shape the choice itself. A car that costs £5,000 less to buy but loses £12,000 more in value over five years is no bargain.
Toyota's dominance of every resale value ranking isn't accidental. It reflects decades of consistency in reliability, strong used-market demand, and disciplined supply. For buyers who care about total cost of ownership, that's the clearest signal the data sends.
If you're drawn to an EV or a luxury model, go in knowing the numbers. The Jaguar I-Pace losing 72% of its value over five years isn't a surprise to anyone who looked at the data in advance. Being surprised by that figure after the fact is expensive.